Skip to main content

Doctor Patient Relationship

An individual professionally trained to treat an ill and suffering person (patient) is a doctor. And their natural relationship is a bilateral one.

When a doctor is sincere, focused, patient, persistent with ethical conduct, a continuous learner, and doing keen observation – it is certain that doctor–patient relationship is the most enduring and satisfying relationship where the doctor learns to hear and see with heart and mind. This healthy and strong relationship will survive forever. (A)

Doctors and patients are the two sides of the same coin fighting their common enemy: disease. In fact, medicine is not a mere profession, it is a calling, a mission, or perhaps even devotion. (C)

During sickness, the patient and his entire family look up to only one person after God and that is the doctor. In the old days, when doctors relied more on their clinical skills than on investigation, patients trusted them with full faith. In those old days doctor was a healthcare giver, philosopher, guide, and teacher – a member of the family while considering this complicated doctor–patient relationship we will have to consider the factors related to their relationship.

Machines: Modern-day medical practice is full of technology bringing modern machines – diagnosing the disease with pathological, radiological, and other aids. They are meant to augment Doctor’s ability to diagnose and not replace them totally. The “S” singularity of machines tries to replace a doctor but that is not possible. (E)

The corporatization of medical treatment has given all the seriousness under one roof with all the modern medical instruments and highly trained doctors. But sadly it took away the human touch. Compassion became a victim of greed on one side (doctor) and unfulfillable demands of the patient on the other. Ultimately strange bitterness invaded the holy patient-doctor duo. (F)

Media: Print, electronic and social media also played a hoax. In hunger for sensationalization and increasing viewership, the media failed to paint the true picture: “especially from the doctor’s point of view” leading to doubt and low regard for the humble profession of doctors. (G)

Google: Huge influence of knowledge given via youtube – Wikipedia – WhatsApp group – made patients think, “they know everything”. They understand the disease and treatment. In fact, details on Google are neither right nor authentic. Patients trust all they read there, putting doctors on backfoot. (H)
Doctors are not God, but merely an instrument of God. Not everyone can and will be cured. (I)
Complications are bound to happen in the best of hands with almost care. Doctors should seek another colleague's opinion to seek support and involve as many other doctors as possible.

Mob Violence: Unending patients’, expectations and politically supported gangs who exploit doctors lead to mob violence. Arrogant, ill-behaved, and threatening relatives do violence leading to physical assault on doctors, damaging hospital premises, and destroying precious instruments. Though few patients are troublemakers, all are not. They make doctors monsters from demigods. Mob violence makes doctors feel timed, gutless, and easily terrified. Doctors become zero from heroes. 75% of doctors in India have faced violence once or more times. (Y)

Medicine is not mathematics and so no single formula can be applied to one and all. Every patient is different and multiple factors play a role in the end result. But without understanding all these details, a judge with little knowledge of medicine and overcharging exploiting lawyers decides the amount of compensation. With the fear of this law, doctors give defensive treatment, advise detailed investigation and refer the patient to a higher center for treatment.

So, present day, three requirements are medically trained judges, legal media restrictions, and appropriate remuneration to doctors.

The remuneration of doctors is always expected to be low telling it to be the profession of human service. Everyone expects discounts when it comes to the payment for health. Medicine is a noble profession, but it is still a business and so doctors need to be paid fairly for their talent. This expectation of low charges, generous, and charity doers can not be satisfied, because expenses for medical education, hospital premises & staff salaries, modern-day costly instruments, and government taxes demand a big amount of money.

The life of a doctor is worth studying before discussing anything. Doctors never refuse a call from the patient. Sleep deprivation and stress are the killing factors leading to five to six years less life for a doctor than the general public. All are allowed to fail, but doctors do not have that luxury. When complications arise, doctors become sleepless, tense, stressed, and has the feeling of anger, shame, and humiliation. Remember, doctors, too, are human and doctors too are only human. Doctors miss numerous family dinners, birthdays, marriage and even visiting their dying relations. They have no family life and sometimes face failed marital relations leading to divorce. Female doctors have more problems because they have to look after domestic work settings, husbands- children, elderly, and sometimes they have to cook in addition to days work of medical practice.

So medicine is an art of healing. Doctors can cure the patient with empathy, meaningful conversation, and sometimes with just a reassuring smile. If a doctor can communicate effectively with the patient and his family and take time to explain the disease, its prognoses, limitations of the doctor himself, and probable charges of the bill, the patients are ready to accept even the most.

Black sheep: However for every failing guilty doctor, thousands are honest, treat countless patients tirelessly and make their life better.

Similarly, for every inconsiderate patient, thousands are grateful and make the doctor's life journey worthwhile.

Corruption and greediness are related to society in general and are reflected in both doctors and patients.

I will summarise the long story short telling a few more things.

Healing touch: Some doctors have a healing touch that works wonders and transforms the patient’s life.

Faith: 100% faith is a must. 1% fear with faith means fraud! Faith infuses positive thoughts, expectations, and communication in the patient.

Law of attraction: Here one says that you can attract whatever you wish.

Law of acceptance: Death is inevitable. Doctors can only do their best to postpone it. Doctors can treat, but can not decide the outcome (end result).

Be non-judgemental: Sometimes there is an end of life. It is time for people to go and they do. The doctor must never feel that he can confer immortality to any patient.

Spirituality is an individual's search for the ultimate meaning of life mixed with humanism, rationalism, and naturalism. It plays a major role in healing. Spiritual dimension showing prayer with great faith in God, chanting mantras repeatedly and meditation do have a great role in healing. Cultivating optimism and positive emotions can counter depression and make healing faster.

Ralph Waldo Emerson said:
The purpose of life is not to be happy, it is to be useful, to be compassionate, and to make some difference that “you have lived and lived well.”
Take home message:
Despite longanimity of life, eradication of many diseases by vaccines and cure by transplanting vital organs, nobody is going to live a healthy life forever. So doctor’s help in curing physical illness is a must and doctors have voluntarily chosen to be a healer by profession. Thus doctor – patients relationship is compulsory.
Present-day society: “full of stress, hurry, corruption, infighting and having suspicion all around” has to be accepted as a reality. Few of the doctors and patients may not be honest and well behaved respectively. Both have to rationalize the relationship. Patients should find out a reasonably clever – honest and compassionate doctor around. Afterward, the patient should trust the doctor, have full faith, and tell him the details of illness and addictions. Doctors should be cautious regarding treatment, charges, and their own safety against violence.

 
Dear People, with Love and Care, Your Doctors
  • Book Title: Dear People, with Love and Care, Your Doctors: Heartfelt Stories about Doctor-Patient Relationship
  • Author: Debraj Shome and Aparna Govil Bhaskar
  • Book Review: by Dr. Bharat Desai, Date: 07-Dec-2022
  • Price: ₹ 389
  • Pages: 298+22
  • Publisher: Bloomsbury, New Delhi (2019)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

સીમંત - સીમંતોન્નયન સંસ્કાર

હિન્દુઓમાં લગ્ન પછી મા-બાપ થવાની પહેલી વારની અવસ્થાનું ખૂબ મહત્વ છે. ગર્ભમાં રહેલ બાળકને શુદ્ધ કરવું – પવિત્ર કરવું જરૂરી હોવાથી તે બાબતનું સંસ્કરણ કરવામાં આવે છે. તેથી જીવન દરમ્યાન થતાં સોળ સંસ્કારોમાંથી એક સીમંતોન્નયન સંસ્કાર ખૂબ જરૂરી છે. આ વિધિ ગર્ભાવસ્થાના અંતિમ તબક્કામાં છઠ્ઠા કે આઠમા માહિનામાં કરવામાં આવે છે. બાળક જન્મ પહેલાના સમયગાળામાં માતાની મન:સ્થિતિની સીધી અસર બાળક ઉપર પડે છે – એટલે આનંદોત્સવ મનાવવાથી સ્ત્રીનું મન આ સમય દરમ્યાન પ્રસન્ન રહે છે જેથી બાળક પણ તંદુરસ્ત રહે છે. ઘરમાં બાળક આવવાના સમાચાર માત્રથી સમગ્ર પરિવારમાં ઉત્સાહ અને આનંદનું વાતાવરણ હોય છે અને સૌ આતુરતાથી આવનાર બાળક મહેમાનના આગમનની રાહ જોતાં હોઈ છે. સીમંત વિધિ  (ખોળો ભરવો – गोद भराई – Baby Shower) શબ્દસહ સમજીએ તો સીમંત એટલે વાળ અને ઉન્નયન એટલે ઉપર ચઢાવવા. વિધિની શરૂઆતમાં પતિ મંત્ર બોલી પત્નીના વાળ સજાવે છે અને સેંથામાં સિંદુર પૂરે છે. સંસ્કૃત મંત્ર દ્વારા કહે છે : “દેવતાઓની માતા અદિતીના સીમંતોન્નયન સંસ્કાર પ્રજાપતિઓને કર્યા હતા અને અદિતીના પેટે દેવતાઓ જન્મ્યા હતા એમ હું સીમંતોન્નયન શ્રેષ્ઠ અન...

Anavils - An Endangered Community

After Parsis, Anavils ( Anavil Brahmins , અનાવિલ બ્રાહ્મણ ) are the fastest decreasing community. The total population of Anavils around the world does not exceed two lakhs figure and that is also fast reducing day by day. Days are not far, beyond a century or so, when they will have to be seen/found in records, photos, and videos. Why? Because,    - they get married too late,    - many are dying unmarried,    - they wait for the career to be settled before the first (and maybe the only) childbirth. So,    The number of children per couple is either one or zero.    It is certain that nothing can save this community from extinction - vanishing! Let me try to introduce this community. Mr. Klass W VanDer Veen - a Dutch scholar and Professor at Amsterdam University prepared a thesis on "Anavils" and wrote a book "I Give Thee My Daughter ". He concluded, "Anavils are smart, efficient, and clever but heavily disunited....

દક્ષિણ ગુજરાતના હળપતિઓનું લોકનૃત્ય “ઘેરીયા”

હૃદયવિણાને ઝણઝણાવીને વાત્સલ્ય, ઉત્સાહ અને કરુણભાવના સંમિશ્રણથી લોકબોલીની તાજગી, વેશભૂષા, તાલ-લય-ઢાળની એકાકારીતા(Harmony) ધરાવતું હળપતિઓની દ્વારા પ્રયોજતું લોકનૃત્ય તે ઘેરીયા . તેની વિગતો સમજવા પહેલા હળપતિ સમાજનો પરિચય કેળવીએ. ડૉ. પી.જી.શાહ, સ્વ.ડૉ. ઠાકોરભાઈ બી. નાયક, સ્વ.માધુભાઈ પટેલ ઉપરાંત હમણાં ડોક્ટર ઈશ્વરચંદ્ર એમ. દેસાઈ અને શ્રી વિનોદચંદ્ર જી. દેસાઈ (C.A.) દ્વારા થયેલા સંશોધનનો લેખ આપણને જરૂરી વિગતો આપે છે. જેને ડૉ. ઈશ્વરચંદ્ર દેસાઈ અને શ્રી વિનોદચંદ્ર દેસાઈએ “ઘેરીયા” નૃત્ય અને ગીતો પુસ્તક દ્વારા આપણી સમક્ષ ઠાલવી છે. હળપતિ કોમના લોકોનું મૂળ વતન આફ્રિકાની પૂર્વ પટી મનાય છે. તેમના રક્તબીજ આફ્રિકાના નીગ્રો ને મળતા આવે છે તેમની શરીર રચના હોઠ, કપાળ આંખો કે રૂપરંગ નીગ્રો ને મળતા આવે છે. તેઓના મૂળ રાઠોડ રાજપૂત સમાજના છે ૧૯૪૯ માં વેડછીના જુગતરામ દવે એ તેમને હળપતિનું સર્વસ્વીકૃત નામ આપ્યું તે પહેલા તેઓ દુબળા તરીકે ઓળખાતા. દુબળા શબ્દ પરથી આવ્યો છે જેને અર્થ વળે નહીં તેવા, અફર જક્કી થાય છે. એમણે લીધેલ નિર્ણય બદલવો મુશ્કેલ. શરીર અને મનથી અવિકસિત કે અર્ધ વિકસિત હોવાથી પણ દુબળા સંબોધન અર્થસુચક છ...

Are Old-age-homes Meant For My Parents?

Or if I may ask, are my parents worth sending and keeping in an old-age-home? The need for time demands more and more old-age-homes to be built. Because: Expense: No problem. Monthly payment amount: No problem. Servants, cook and other staff needed: No problem. Whatever has to be done: No problem!

વસિયતનામું (Will)

વસિયતનામું એક લખાણ (Document) છે જેના દ્વારા લખનારની મિલકતના ભાગલા અને ફેરબદલ (Transfer) લખનારના મૃત્યુ બાદ નિર્દેષીત વ્યક્તિઓ કે સંસ્થાને કરવામાં આવે છે. કાનૂની(Legal) રીતે માન્ય દસ્તાવેજ-વસિયતનામું લખનારની મિલકતની પોતાના મૃત્યુ બાદ વહેંચણી બાબતે માહિતી આપે છે. વસિયત લખવાનો હેતુ લખનારનું મન અને ઇચ્છાને સરળતાથી કહેવાનો છે.  વસિયતનામું મિલકત ધરાવનાર કોઈપણ વ્યક્તિ વારસદારોને આપવાની ઈચ્છા જણાવવા કરી શકે છે  વસિયત ૧૮ વર્ષથી ઉપરનો પુખ્ત વ્યક્તિ (સ્ત્રી કે પુરુષ) કરી શકે છે.  વસિયત લખનારની માનસિક હાલત સ્વસ્થ હોવી જોઈએ.  વસિયત લખવાની સરકારી એજન્સી દ્વારા મનાઈ ન ફરમાવેલ હોવું જોઈએ. પ્રોબેટ (Probate) Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 2 મુજબ પ્રોબેટ યોગ્ય ન્યાયાલય દ્વારા વસિયતનામાની કાયદેસર(Legation) સચ્ચાઈ(Correction) અને પ્રમાણિકતાની(Genuineness) ખાતરી આપતો હુકમ (Decree) છે પશ્ચિમ બંગાળ, બિહાર, ઓરિસ્સા, આસામ ઉપરાંત દિલ્હી, મુંબઈ, અને ચેન્નઈ નો મ્યુનિસિપલ કોર્પોરેશન હદ ના રહેવાસીઓ માટે પ્રોબેટ ફરજિયાત છે મૃત્યુના સાત દિવસ પછી પ્રોબેટ માટે અરજી થઈ શકે છે. Indian Succession ...

મૃત્યુનું મનોમંથન

ભારત માં જન્મને શુભ અને મૃત્યુ ને અશુભ કહ્યું છે. હકીકતમાં જ્ન્મ-મૃત્યુ બન્ને એક સિક્કાની બે બાજુઓ છે જે બન્ને પરસ્પર જોડાયેલા છે. મૃત્યુની શરૂઆત જન્મથી થાય છે અને તેથી જ તો અનેક અનિશ્ચિત ચિતતાઓને કારણે વ્યક્તિ કોઈપણ ઉંમરે મૃત્યુ પામે છે. ભારતમાં આઝાદી સમયે ૧૯૪૭માં જીવનની અપેક્ષા જન્મ સમયે ૩૭ વર્ષ હતી, તે આજે ૨૦૨૨ માં લગભગ ૭૦ વર્ષ છે (life expectancy at birth). તેમાંય પુરુષનું જીવનકાળ ૬૭.૪ વર્ષ અને સ્ત્રીનો જીવનકાળ ૭૦.૩ વર્ષ એટલેકે લગભગ ૩ વર્ષ ઓછો હોય છે. મરણના મુખ્ય દસ કારણોમાં હ્રદયરોગ ૨૫%, શ્વસનતંત્ર રોગ ૧૦%, ટી.બી. ૧૦%, કેન્સર ૧૦% છે. તો અનિર્ણિત માંદગી, પાચનતંત્રના રોગ, ઝાડા અને અકસ્માત દરેક પાંચ-પાંચ ટકા છે. અને આપઘાત અને મેલેરિયા ત્રણ-ત્રણ ટકા છે. એટલે કે ભારતમાં લગભગ સિત્તેર વર્ષના જીવન પછી હ્રદયરોગથી મરણ ની શક્યતા સૌથી વધુ છે. હા, અમારા દક્ષિણ ગુજરાત નાં અનાવિલ બ્રહ્માણ સમાજમાં મૃત્યુની ઉંમર ૮૪ વર્ષની આસપાસ છે! કરુણતા પૂર્વક સ્વીકારવું રહ્યું કે વર્તમાન મેડિકલ વિજ્ઞાન ને કારણે પહેલાંની જેમ મૃત્યુની ઘડી જલ્દી આવતી નથી અને વૃદ્ધ માણસ બીમાર પડીને તરત મૃત્યુ પામતો નથી, પણ હોસ...

Long Vacation At Bengaluru

After voluntary retirement as Government Medical Officer, my wife Dr Bhavana (Devyani) wanted to have a vacation and I joined her. The long break of 14 days (2 weeks) was starting on date 9th March 2011 and ending on 23rd March 2011. We planned to stay at Rahul’s (our son) residence at Bangalore and return to Bilimora. Vacation - is stopping the continuous job/work and retire at some place at leisure. We know vacation is a change of activity and we did that. It is a recess, say a break or temporary cessation of routine work. Is vacation necessary ?

Dawood Ibrahim - A Journey From Dongri To Karachi, Via Dubai

One of the recent off-bit topics I’ve read, this one book about ‘Mumbai Mafia’ has been the most interesting, well-researched and well-written. Here is an excerpt from Dawood Ibrahim's journey from “Dongri to Dubai”, and the six decades of Mumbai mafia.

Void After My Father's Departure

One year back, I was writing about myself in an article Death at 60 . I wrote there I was ready to die at any time, but given a choice, I would like to wait until my father was alive. My purpose for this demand of concession was my desire to support my father morally and physically in his old age. Well, he did not agree to this and went away forever on his own. So, I can loudly pronounce now “I am ready to die!” However, I have yet to learn how to react to someone when I disagree with them and/or my ideas differ in total from the concerned person. At present, in such situations, I keep myself away and withdraw. It can be labeled as escapism . But coming to a consensus or agreement is not always easy. Due to the generation gap or the conservative approach of parents, the difference of opinion is bound to be there. Here, both parties should take care of maintaining the dignity of the other. The ideal option is to ignore the nature of the parents and forgive them immediately.

Karmic Theory (Law Of Karma)

“Facing Challenges and Creating Destiny” by BK Shivani, Gurgaon National Conference on Mind-Body-Medicine, Mount Abu. August 6-10, 2010 What is Karma? Karma is work or energy going out in the form of 1. Thought, 2. Word and/or 3. Action. Resultant return of energy is in the same amount known as Bhagya (Destiny). The role of God is to ask you to do Karma and to help you to do the RIGHT karma. Then whatever good/bad karma you do, the result is accordingly and entirely your responsibility. Because the result is Destiny (Bhagya). So don’t blame anyone else or God for anything bad. Do not try to blame someone responsible for your own deed and its result. Be aware and create/decide your own destiny (Bhagya). Actually, the role of God is to: Give us the strength to handle the problem/situation Accompany us in solving the issue Guide Love unconditionally Give proper knowledge and Pour power to face the situation So pause a little before doing something wrong, think it will ...