Skip to main content

What Went Wrong In The History of India

For those who do not learn from history, history teaches them a lesson at a great cost.
We - the Indians - neither create history nor read history, and so writing the history is far from even dreaming of. Therefore, more often than not, we became silent spectators and slaves praising the people who made marks in history. History is repeated every often because we never read it and so never learn anything whatsoever. We do not have a record of history beyond 2000 years because we never found it worth writing and keeping a record of. No wonder, books of history give us their viewpoint – biased – written by either Mughals as Babarnama, British or Chinese student Hu-En-Sang. It was not before 1000 years that Indian scholar Acharya Hemchandra wrote Siddh-Hem telling a total history of the said period of Kind Siddhraj Jaisinh rule. Again, a blackout occurred.

Before coming to what went wrong in our history, I must briefly explain how politics in India evolved.

Evolution of politics in India:
  • Gan Rajya: 2600 years back, we had Gan Rajya where the state was ruled by a group of people elected by the public. The King was elected out of them. So there was no birth-right that made any one a King. In this system, corruption and in-fighting started. Ultimately inheritance and birth-right led to becoming King.
  • Brahmins: Now, I should tell you about Brahmins who invented the caste-system in the Vedic period. They divided the total population into four groups according to the profession. Brahmin, Kshatriya, Vaishya and Sudra. The fourth in the series – Sudra – was asked to do service as a servant. Initially, caste-system was on the basis of the work done by the individual and not on the basis of inheritance, which later on turned to birth. The caste-system made a class of superior and inferior human. The insulting and inhuman mannerism of untouchability entered. Bhagwan Mahaveer in Jainism and Buddha in Buddhism corrected this telling all men are same.
  • Kings: In Magadha Kingdom, the first ever big state having 80,000 villages king Bimbisar ruled as one belonging to Shishunag dynasty. He was killed by his san Ajatsatru who ruled as a king. Similarly, all six kings were killed by their sons to become king earlier. Seeing all these non-sense killings, people got fed up. They installed one minister as King. The last King in this dynasty Dhananad insulted his minister – Chanakya. Chanakya (321 BC) found out Chandragupta Maurya (321 BC – 296 BC) and became his advisor, guide and mentor. Chandragupta became the king of Patliputra (Patna). Chanakya said if the King is industrious – hard-working – people of his reign will be so.
  • Jaichand: in 1192, Jaichand alias Jaichandra Rathod of Kannauj invited Mohammed Ghori; went to his camp to tell war-plans of Prithviraj and secrets of their army. Invader Mohammed Ghori easily won the battle. Poor India then became the Islamic nation in no time.
  • Mir Jafar: In 1757, Mohammed Jafar Ali Khan Bahadur (Mir Jafar) – then chief of the army in Nawab Siraj-Ud-Daula of Bengal rule – had lust and ambition to become Nawab. He became traitor and did a breach of trust in the war of Plasi. So company head British Robert Clive won the battle and established British rule over India in no time to pass.

We are always divided and those two segments never unit – I am talking about,
  • Caste: Hindu higher caste and Hindy lower caste of Harijans.
  • Religion: Hindu, Muslim, Christian, etc.
  • Economic groups: Rich – higher income group and Poor – meagre or low-income group.
  • Qualification: Highly qualified and illiterate.
  • Gender: Male and female.
Imaginary gap and distance are so much that unification of either of above is nearly impossible. This tells us – we are never united as one nation – patriotism is strictly limited to the books. For personal gains, we are ready to be traitor and do any breach of trust. Jaichand brought Mughals and Mir Jafar brought British as rulers of India. Agreed. But today as well, the scene is no different. All are ready to become either or Jaichand or Mir Jafar.

Why independent India is ruled by a single family?

All this detailed explanation telling about our mentality – psychology – of being impressed by non-Indians – foreigners, especially one having less darker skin colour, leads to the conclusion that we can easily be ruled by others. I am not going to the extreme of telling we can easily be made slaves. So, present day rule of Congress led by Sonia Gandhi and her son Rahul Gandhi is no exception to this. The single-family birth-right rule fits in the past and their dominance on the total Indian public is just natural.

Well, do I want to learn something from the History? As expected, if negative answer follows, we are born to live as slaves and second-grade citizen in our own country - if not Moghals or British as in past – Americans, Russians or any who want to dominate us. We are hardworking, intelligent and great administrators. What will act is will to learn the art of self-respect and self-discipline. Why should I feel inferior? Why should I ask anyone (say Americans) about policies of our nation? If this will continue, dominance by all around like Americans, Pakistanis or Chinese or any is not far to fetch.

Who can help us? Nobody? Oneself? I don’t know. You tell me...

Image source:

Read other readers' comments.



  1. Hmmm.... so thus we write!

    Being an ardent lover of the mighty English language, I could not help but cringe at the grammatical error in the very first line of the blog.

    Nevertheless, as I read further, your inability to use English properly was evident in full glory.

    I always believe one should write in the language one is most comfortable with. Trying to use a language in which one is not proficient leads to a massacre of content.

    The photograph chosen for the blog smacks of your political leanings which for an apolitical person like me doesn't matter, but at the same time lends bias to your presentation.

    The most disconcerting part of this blog is its lack of coherence. The unifying thread of theory is missing in the write-up.

    Nevertheless, good try, Doc! Will try to read more of your writings.

    Ek Anavil


      I thank you for your comment.
      Well, I am happy about criticism.
      I am sure you must be expert in the subject.


    2. Aasav, (if that means anything worthy)

      Only if you had any knowledge of blogging, online publishing, or this subject matter to begin with. Your anonymity speaks for your lack of knowledge and more importantly the insubstantial personality you must be struggling with. My sympathies to your family and the people who must put up with a waste of a human being, a classic worthless-spineless-arrogant an 'Anavil' you are!

      I can write more if you need more soup of the 'mighty English' language... Do write back.


Post a Comment

Optionally, you can also email your feedback directly to the author.

Also popular this week:

Anavils - An Endangered Community

After Parsis, Anavils (Anavil Brahmins, અનાવિલ બ્રાહ્મણ ) are the fastest decreasing community. The total population of Anavils around the world does not exceed two lakhs figure and that is also fast reducing day by day. Days are not far, beyond a century or so, when they will have to be seen/found in records, photos and videos. Why?

   - they get married too late,    - many are dying unmarried,    - they wait for the career to be settled before the first (and maybe the only) childbirth.

Rahul & Shivani's Wedding

Whatever smartness or intelligence one has, to anticipate the probable attitude of the future partner is difficult. So for the continuation of the marriage, adjustment and compromises are must, compulsory.

One has to marry because the law does not allow man-woman physical relations at random and society has laid certain norms of man-woman staying together. Though liberate present-day scenario allows live-in relations and physical relationship without much fuss, marriages are unavoidable.

Once decided to marry, the second question arising is the method – the technique of the wedding. How many persons to be invited, the place of the wedding, the menu and its preparation and the details of the function is the subject of this article.

My Books - My Treasure

During a candid chat with Prof. Dr Ashwin Desai in Surat one fine day, he asked me about the list of books I possess and I had no answer! I thought why not prepare an inventory, along with an article containing a brief description and their photographs.

I also happened to read an article in Reader’s Digest around the same time about the set of books the lady author owned. She advised to keep books around - within reach and there were chances of your reading the book. She advocated to keep on purchasing the books, so that one day you may come out reading the precious collection you have already purchased at a sky-high expense. Let me describe them and I wish photos speak more.

1. Academic Books on Ophthalmology and General Medicine: Being a life member of the Indian Medical Association New Delhi (IMA) and All India Ophthalmology Society (AIOS), the journals and proceedings made my first heap of books. Yes, I have read them. I have books on Ophthalmology purchased off an…

જમ્મુ-કાશ્મીરનો અજાણ્યો ઈતિહાસ

આપણે સમાચાર તરીકે જમ્મુ-કાશ્મીરની વાતો રોજ સાંભળીએ છીએ, પણ વિગતવાર ઊંડાણપૂર્વકની માહિતીના અભાવે વાત ખાસ સમજાતી નથી. ચાલો, પહેલાં મૂળ વાતો બરાબર સમજીયે.

જમ્મુ-કાશ્મીરનો ઈતિહાસ
૧૮૨૨: મહારાજા ગુલાબસિંહ જમ્મુની ગાદીએ બેઠા.૧૮૪૬: જમ્મુ અને કાશ્મીર બન્ને એક રાજ્ય બન્યા. ઈસ્ટ ઈન્ડિયા કંપની અને મહારાજા ગુલાબસિંહ વચ્ચે અમૃતસર સંધિ થઈ.૧૮૫૭: સ્વતંત્રતાની પહેલી લડાઈ… મહારાજા ગુલાબસિંહનું મરણ.૧૯૪૭: ભારત વિભાજન સાથે ભારત અને પાકિસ્તાન એમ બે ભાગમાં સ્વતંત્ર થયું.રર-૧૦-૪૭: જમ્મુ-કાશ્મીર પર પાકિસ્તાને કબાલીયો વડે આક્રમણ કર્યું અને ૧/૩ ભાગ કબજે કર્યો.૨૬-૧૦-૪૭: મહારાજા હરિસિંહ ભારત જોડાણ પત્ર પર સહી કરી… જમ્મુ-કાશ્મીરનું ભારતમાં જોડાણ.૩9-૧૦-૪૭: શેખ અબ્દુલ્લા આપાત પશાસક નીમાયા.૧૭-૧૧-૪૭: પ્રજા પરિષદ પક્ષની સ્થાપના.

મોરારજી દેસાઈ

ભારતના ભૂતપૂર્વ વડાપ્રધાન શ્રી. મોરારજી દેસાઈ આપણી વચ્ચે જીવ્યા અને મર્યા. તેમને માટે આપણને સૌને ગર્વ છે. કારણ તેઓ ગુજરાતી હતા. આપણી જેમ અનાવિલ હતા અને ગરીબ પરિવારના સભ્ય હતા. તો પણ ભારતના રાજકિય સર્વોચ્ચ પદ વડાપ્રધાન પદે સ્વબળે પહોચ્યા હતા. તેઓ આપણા હતા આપણી સાથે હતા જીવ્યા હતા. આપણે તેમને સરળતાથી મળીને વાતચીત કરી શકતા હતા. છતાં તેમનો પરિચય મને કહેવા દો.

મોરારજી દેસાઈનો સ્વભાવ

સાચો પરિચય ખૂબ ઓછા લોકોને હતો. આથી તેમના વિષે ઘણી ગેરસમજો પ્રવર્તતી હતી. તેમના વિષે પૂર્વગ્રહથી લખાતી માહિતીઓ દ્વારા આપણે તેમને ઓળખતા થયા હતા. ત્યારે તેમનો સ્વભાવ જીદ્દી, તુંડમિજાજી, અભિમાની કે ખૂબ જ કડક હોવાની ખોટી માન્યતા હતી. તે દૂર કરવાનો અને સાચી રીતે તેમને ઓળખાવવાનો પ્રયત્ન અહી મેં કર્યો છે. મોરારજી દેસાઈના સ્વભાવનો પરિચય કરાવવા અને તેમને થતો અન્યાય નિવારવા હું તેમની આત્મકથામાંથી દેખાતા અને ઉદભવતા તેમના સ્વભાવની વાત કરીશ. ચાલો, પહેલા ટૂંકો પરિચય જાણીએ.

ટૂંકો જીવન પરિચય
૨૯.૦૨.૧૮૯૬ વલસાડ જીલ્લાના ભદેલી ગામે મોસાળમાં જન્મપ્રાથમિક શિક્ષણ : ભદેલી અને સાવરકુંડલામાધ્યમિક શિક્ષણ : શેઠ આર.જે.જે.હાઈ સ્કૂલ અને બાઈ આવ…